Provenance
The subject, Philadelphia, died 1821
his son, Richard Willing, Philadelphia, died 1858
his daughter, Ellen Willing
her brother, Edward Shippen Willing, Bryn Mawr, Pennsylvania (according to a label on the stretcher)
his daughter, Ava Lowle Willing (Mrs. John Jacob Astor, later Lady Ribblesdale), died 1925
her grandson, Ivan Obolensky, by 1964 until 1966
with Robert G. Osborne New York, 1966
1