Provenance
George Gibbs, New York (1795)
his sister, Mrs. William E. Channing, Boston (before 1833-57)
her son, William F. Channing, Providence, Rhode Island (1857-89)
Samuel Putnam Avery Sr., New York (1889-d. 1904)
his son, Samuel Putnam Avery Jr., New York (1904-7)