With Samuel Putnam Avery, New York, 1866
John Taylor Johnston, New York, 1866–76
sale, Somerville Art Gallery, New York, 20 December 1876, nr. 181
Robert Lenox Kennedy, New York, 1876–died 1887
his sister, Mary Lenox Kennedy, New York, 1887–died 1917
her great-grandniece, Rachel Lenox Kennedy (Mrs. Frank B.) Porter, New York, until 1922